Skip to content

Biting the hand that feeds IT

The Register ®

Comms:


Related Whitepapers

Comments on ‘Bournemouth floats UK's first 100Mbps sewer broadband network’

Insert fibre/ Wii/ pipe/ download / backdoor/ flush/ log pun here

Published Thursday 8th May 2008 08:02 GMT

« Back to article page

bmth rocks 

By Geoff Spick
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 08:13 GMT
Happy

Yay, finally a chance to ditch Virgin. Hope the prices are competitive, if not super-cheap as we're testing this stuff for them.

Come on down, the water's lovely - http://www.bournemouth-surfing.co.uk/community-cams.htm

Happy because Bournemouth is great

Southampton Plxes? 

By Andrew
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 08:17 GMT
Thumb Up

Be nice if we could have such technology in our city! The council is already fibre-linked together!

Then again, what PHORM ideas will they apply to such connection?

Its about time too... we're so far behind in internet technology.

Silver surfing at the speed of light... 

By Tony Chandler
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 08:23 GMT

I don't see why they've picked Bournemouth - surely downloading knitting patterns and shopping online for hairnets, dog food and incontinence pants can all be done perfectly well over an ADSL connection?

Cable to the door... 

By GrahamT
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 08:27 GMT
Boffin

quote: "get the cable to the door via a 20mm-wide, 100mm-deep channel."

Is a 4inch deep cable going to be safe from 6 inch long spade or fork? Or do people with high speed broadband have no time for gardening?

Re: silver surfing 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 08:40 GMT

Clearly Tony's not visited sunny Bournemouth in a while. It's all students, tourists and stag parties. We're the Ibiza of England, dontcha know.

@ AC re "Ibiza of England" 

By Matthew
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 08:45 GMT
Coat

Yup, still glad I've never been to Bournemouth!

350 pounds per connection? 

By Christian Berger
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 08:50 GMT

Wow, that's actually rather cheap. I would love to pay 350 pounds for a fiber to my home.

Hopefully this will just be bare ethernet so you will already have a network to your neighbours for free.

Lay cable? 

By Darren Lovell
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 08:52 GMT
Coat

"H2O Networks, a start-up we wrote about earlier this year, will lay cable to more than 88,000 homes at a cost of about £30m."

Dear God! What were they eating if they could lay cable to that many homes?

Mine's the one with the laxatives in the pockets.

Keep off the Grass 

By ED Stroudley
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 08:52 GMT

"Is a 4inch deep cable going to be safe from 6 inch long spade or fork?"

= Standard procedure for telephone utilities in US of A subbubs

4inch deep tube 

By Steve
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 09:06 GMT
Happy

I should imagine that the cable itself will be protected in some kind of ducting when traversing gardens. Certainly my VM connection is, which was lucky as they'd gone through the roots of the Leylandii that I dug up last summer (manually, though not with much care... :)

@Anonymous Coward re England's ibiza 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 09:11 GMT

Poet's Corner still there? And what about the Zoo? Haven't been to Bournmouth for ages. As far as I remember it's all students and heaven's waiting room.

EAfH

(bloody Ibiza, btw. Never been there, never will be.)

Fibre in their diets? 

By JP Sistenich
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 09:11 GMT
Coat

At least this should help Bournemouth keep (data flow) regular then...

The one with the hard hat and gas mask please...

@GrahamT 

By MarmiteToast
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 09:12 GMT

6 inch spade? Isn't that rather a trowel?

re: re: Silver surfing 

By Tony Chandler
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 09:15 GMT

Oh, am I behind the times? Sorry.

What happened to all the old folks? Did they all die off, or are they all too scared to leave their homes due to marauding herds of tourists, students and stag parties?

re: re: re: Silver surfing 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 09:32 GMT
Paris Hilton

Old people can be found lurking in Bournemouth's many suburbs. We sacrifice the town centre to tourists and stag groups in the summer, still plenty of nice little pubs for us locals, and if you're smart you'll walk a mile along the beach away from the pier to find a nice quiet spot by the sea.

@AC

The Zoo and Cage is long gone. It's 'Elements' and (dear lord) 'Disco Fever' now. Never been in there, never will.

@Matthew

You should visit. It's a lovely town, not a seaside ghetto. Just don't come in July or August if you can't cope with crowds.

Paris 'cos we have no shortage of scantily-clad ladies in the summer months

Don't know what the fuss is about 

By Tom
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 09:33 GMT
Coat

I've been laying cables into the sewers for years...

Mines the one with the HAZ MAT breather gear.....

Google 

By Jon Pain
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 10:07 GMT

Does this not remind anybody of one of google's april fool hoaxes?

http://www.google.com/tisp/

bottleneck? 

By Andrew Smith
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 10:13 GMT

So everyone has a superfast connection and decides to use it each evening when they get home from work. What kind of connection do they have coming into Bournemouth?

You dirty rat 

By Alan Parsons
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 10:16 GMT
Stop

Wow - didn't know there were so many of us 'Bournemouthians' on here.. But has anyone thought out the true consequences of this? Fibre can be passively tapped and rats have been shown to be worrying intelligent creatures. Bear with me. We're all eating GM food and pooing it out. So what happens if we get uber-intelligent, oversize rats with a penchant for stripping fibre and the teeth to do it? With the number of mobile phones that get flushed they'll have plenty of bits to build a compooter with, plus we all know that you can use poo as a power source.

You don't want to worry about alligators in sewers, it's genetically modified script kiddie rats that are the real issue, and we're handing them a better and faster connection than most of us have. It'll end in tears, but I, for one, welcome our new long tailed, plague bearing overlords.

Or maybe the late great Mr Adams was wrong and it was rats and not mice all along? Seems subtly engineered to me.

Hong Kong 

By Garry Mills
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 10:23 GMT

A friend was boasting about the 100Mbs pipe that he has to his flat in Hong Kong, at least I can say we are getting there.

Apart from the fact that he's got a slow connection, HK broadband offer up to 1 Gbit/s. We are still behind (no pun intended)

Internet from the sewers - wasn't it filthy enough already? 

By Rob Davis
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 10:43 GMT
Joke

So we have sewers to take away our filthy stuff but now the internet comes from there to bring it all back up.

Obligatory observation... 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 11:08 GMT
Coat

I hope it continues to handle the massive surges in downloads, especially right after dinner time...

Connection speeds, contention ratios, etc? 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 11:10 GMT
Dead Vulture

I mean if it's [potentially] 33,000 customers sharing all 100Mbps then that's a little slow- about 3.3kbps.

Then again, that's still faster than my formerly-Pipex-now-Tiscali connection at peak times.

And what's the latency? Sneakernets can both give far higher bandwidth than even gigabit or 10 gigabit connections, and IP over Avian Carrier will be up to that level with holographic storage. But playing Quake over them would still be a little jerky.

If it ends up being [relatively] high latency due to a fairly crap infrastructure it'll not be any good.

It's a new technology and I'm old. It scares me...

Lets just hope it's symmetric upload/download, non-traffic shaped, no FUP, next-to-zero latency, 1:1 contention, etc etc. If it was less than £75 a month for that I'd go for it. £10 a month and I'd buy a few and bind them together into one huge super-'net-pipe.

Oh, and to Alan Parsons: tapping fiber without anyone noticing a dropped connection is orders of magnitudes higher than with Copper (find flat bit of cable, strip outer insulation and armour, and attach IDC connector. Hook each pin up to monitoring equipment. No loss of service unless you're a bad aim with the IDC connectors and no resplicing of fiber. Which is a bitch.).

Dead bird becuase that's a serious problem with IP over Avian Carrier.

@Andrew Smith 

By alistair millington
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 11:13 GMT

The connection coming into town will probably be BT's 21CN, which means it'll be shite and 100 years behind the real world.

Still emailing your mates down the road will be faster and p2p sharing will be great.

Plenty of fibre to keep thing running smoothly 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 11:21 GMT
Boffin

Now all this fibre in the home, surely it will cause a few blockages, hopefully will bring new meaning to the shite service will receive from most ISPs. It could it be said most are going down the drain fast. Or am I just Poo Pooing the idea of a decent ISP. Probably just a lot of hot air about nothing (or should I say methane).

@Jon Pain 

By Fluffykins
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 11:23 GMT

Freudian slip? I read the URL as

http://www.google.com/titsup/

OK

Coat

Going

>slam<

@Poet's Corner still there? And what about the Zoo? 

By It'sa Mea... Mario
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 11:30 GMT
Go

No both changed. P(*ss) O(ff) E(arly) T(omorrow's) S(aturday) is now a fancy resturant, and the Zoo & Cage last I knew were called Elements - although that may have changed since.

Re the Fibre: Go Bournemouth about time we had something first for a change!

Beh.. 

By Martin Nicholls
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 11:42 GMT

Don't think anymore fibre in shitter jokes are needed, they've all been done.

Btw if anybody thinks this service is going to be cheap - you're off your rocker. Well, either you are or h2o are.

Re: Google 

By Gavin Pearce
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 11:47 GMT
Go

Yea I was going to say, Google have already done this :-p

Did the start up nick the idea from Google's April Fools joke? Or the other way round.

Oh please let it be flush and go.

http://www.google.com/tisp/

^^^^ look at it if you haven't alredy ^^^^

Fibre to the bog 

By Richard Porter
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 11:54 GMT
Boffin

Very appropriate, considering the amount of crap that comes over the internet.

Sewer BVroadband Network 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 12:04 GMT
Joke

Does that mean the user will actually be downloading crap onto their PCs?

@It'sa Mea... Mario & AC 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 13:53 GMT

Well, I guess I would be too old now for Zoo or Poet's anyway. I might see whether The Seagull in Boscombe still exists next time I'll come around.

Cheers

EAfH

Keep Off the Grass 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 14:39 GMT
Boffin

The NEC (National Electric Code for US) requires 18-24" burial for communications cables generally (some variation for conduit and such). This does not stop the cable companies from just scratching a tiny trench with a claw hammer and popping a wire in though. Watched them do that I have.

Some cabling has 'integral conduit', which lessens the burial depth, but don't rototill anywhere near it....

But it does me no good, since this is America and there isn't anyone to provide anything but POTS at the property entrance. Digital third world it is.

I have however found that cantennas plus EnGenius (or similar) exterior bridges can stretch several KM LOS. Now, I just need a suitable backhaul point :)

Which Bournemouth? 

By Nick G
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 14:40 GMT
Paris Hilton

Do they mean yer actual Bournemouth or are they including those bits of Poole that Bournemouth likes to claim (such as Bournemouth Uni actually being in Poole)

Paris because she's responsible for many an increase in bandwidth

This [wont] be the world's largest single fibre deployment 

By John Hughes
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 14:53 GMT
Paris Hilton

Look, I know the fact that France is superior to the UK in all ways embarrasses all right thinking brits, but "This will be the world's largest single fibre deployment" is ignorant even for someone from Bournemouth.

A small town called Paris started installing 100mbps fibre last year. Using the sewers even. With that amazing capitalist invention known as competition to keep the prices down.

I can't imagine how to choose the little icon thingy.

@John Hughes 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 15:48 GMT
Stop

"I know the fact that France is superior to the UK in all ways"

Well, at least UK won one or the other war in contrast to France. Otherwise it quite often feels a bit like a second-world country - if it comes to service culture, it's nothing but third-world. But at least with regard to CCTV UK is superior to the rest of the world for being home to half of world-wide cameras. Great!

Says the EAfH defending UK somewhat. And who hates control freaks.

How long? 

By Chris Miller
Posted Thursday 8th May 2008 15:49 GMT

before the first customer complains about the 'totally unreasonable' 3TB per month cap??

As they say... 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Friday 9th May 2008 04:36 GMT
Happy

Shit in, shit out....

GIGO 

By Slaine
Posted Friday 9th May 2008 10:21 GMT
Thumb Up

...garbage in, garbage out. At least now we will have the confidence of knowing that it is travelling along a suitable conduit.

great! 

By Anonymous Coward
Posted Friday 9th May 2008 13:18 GMT
Happy

link encraption comes standard..

ooo I got another one... 

By Slaine
Posted Friday 9th May 2008 13:59 GMT
Joke

It's just perfect for Flush Media.

TADDAAAAA !!! yes, I know, I'm dreadfully sorry for that one.

Fibrecities 

By Banshee
Posted Saturday 10th May 2008 11:05 GMT

Will someone PLEASE tell this company that the city of Kingston-upon-Hull NEEDS this technology !! Hull is the ONLY city in the whole UK that has ZERO choice of ISP or for that matter telco provider. The whole infrastructure including isp servers, phone lines, exchanges, you name it, belong to Kingston Communications and are operated as an effective monopoly which OFCom refuses to even investigate properly.

This fibre by sewers system looks to me like a God-send to us. See this link for further comment/info on the subject from Hull residents themselves on the standards of service and treatment we get >> http://karooforums.net/index.php

Cheap customers 

By I. Aproveofitspendingonspecificprojects
Posted Sunday 11th May 2008 06:01 GMT
Paris Hilton

Bournemouth full of tightwads is it? It would explain this comment:

Its about time too... we're so far behind in internet technology.

There again, so would this:

Hope the prices are competitive, if not super-cheap as we're testing this stuff for them.

Assuming the preliminary figures of £30 million were cooked up by the PR men and that no long term damage to the sewers is involved. And that there are no snags (ha.. in a British sewer?) that is £340 per customer before profit.

And they want it for free?

@Anonymous Coward 

By John
Posted Monday 12th May 2008 10:04 GMT

As an ex-serviceman, it pains me to say it, but "Well, at least UK won one or the other war in contrast to France" just isn't historically accurate. The contribution of the French Army to winning WWI was greater than the British - in killed, wounded, men involved, sectors of the line held, etc. It is also sadly true that Russia won WWII against the Germans, not the West.

More on topic, without more technical info on the service, it's impossible to say if it will be either good or cost-effective. What optical kit are they deploying? Are they using Spanning Tree? RST? VPLS? h-VPLS? Q-in-Q or MAC-in-MAC? We need more info than "fibre at 100Mbps"

PS HK, like most of the much-lauded Far East, only gives good connectivity to high-density MTUs. Try living in the sticks, and see what broadband speeds you get - IP over OX-Cart!

whitepaper title

The Perfect (Virtual) Marriage

Get consistent virtual machine storage savings of 50% (often as high as 90%) with virtually no performance impact with NetApp deduplication..
whitepaper title

Solution Brief: Reduce Energy Costs

Energy consumption has become a big issue. Dramatically increase server utilization and significantly reduce energy costs through Virtualization..

Top 20 storiesAll The Week’s HeadlinesArchiveSearch