Skip to content

Biting the hand that feeds IT

The Register ®

Management:


Related Whitepapers

[Print][Mobile][Alerts]

Websites not liable for third party posts - court

Lawyers stunned by common sense ruling

Published Tuesday 21st November 2006 10:41 GMT

The California Supreme Court issued a unanimous ruling on Monday stating that websites can't be sued over third-party content, the Associated Press reports.

The court found that, according to the Communications Decency Act of 1996, only the person responsible for creating libellous content can be pursued.

At issue was a San Diego woman, Ilena Rosenthal, who is alleged to have slandered a doctor by posting email memos obtained from third parties on her website, the wire service says.

The decision is bad news for lawyers, who naturally take on these cases in hopes of suing the daylights out of rich operators like Google, Yahoo!, MSN, AOL, and the like. Not surprisingly, many of these outfits generously participated on behalf of the defendant.

A Lower California court had ruled that the liability protections provided by the Communications Decency Act did not apply to individual online "distributors" of putatively libellous content, like Rosenthal. But the state Supremes found that "by declaring that no 'user may be treated as a publisher' of third party content, Congress has comprehensively immunised re-publication by individual internet users".

Thus lawyers' lobbying groups will have to go back to Capitol Hill and buy some better legislation, allowing them to sue wealthier targets. ®

Track this type of story as a custom Atom/RSS feed or by email.
Previous Article Next Article
whitepaper title

A Green Vision: Interview with VMWare CEO Diane Greene

This interview with VMware CEO Diane Greene discusses how you can realize the financial benefits of energy efficient, greener datacenters through server consolidation..
whitepaper title

Enabling the Data Center Metamorphosis

This independent analyst paper gives real world advice on transforming your datacenter into a streamlined, dynamic, liquid engine capable of handling growth..
Whitepapers

Top 20 storiesAll The Week’s HeadlinesArchiveSearch